MantisBT

View Issue Details Jump to Notes ] Issue History ] Print ]
IDProjectCategoryView StatusDate SubmittedLast Update
0000204124thATC[All Projects] Generalpublic2016-08-14 14:392016-11-22 05:12
ReporterAdvMichael 
Assigned Tontnll 
PrioritynormalSeverityminorReproducibilitysometimes
StatusassignedResolutionunable to reproduce 
Platformx64OS(All OS)OS Version(All versions)
Product Version2.0-a44 
Target VersionFixed in Version 
Summary0000204: Wrong additional letter added to STAR name?
DescriptionOn my flight to LOWS with the last waypoint "UNKEN" I got the correct STAR "UNKEN" assigned, however 124thATC for some reason called it "UNKEN N" instead of simply "UNKEN" as in the procedure database? Where does the additional letter "N" come from? Below see the related procedure database entries and the log file (look at the last line there).

I started to analyze all SID/STAR names and will shortly post a function specification for correctly using the SID/STAR names in ATC communication. Maybe you wait for this before dealing with this problem report in detail.
Steps To ReproduceHere are the related entries in procedure database:
C:\Users\Michael\Desktop\X-Plane 10\Resources\GNS430\navdata\Proc\LOWS.txt

STAR,UNKEN,ALL,2
IF,UNKEN,47.82166667,12.60111111, ,0.0,0.0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0
TF,SBG4,47.95745000,12.81969722,0, ,0.0,0.0,0,0.00,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0
TF,SBG,48.00244444,12.89288056,0, ,0.0,0.0,0,0.00,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0
Additional Information124thATC v2.0-a44 23:00:16 : reading x-plane navdata from C:\Users\Michael\Desktop\X-Plane 10\Resources\GNS430\navdata\Proc\LOWS.txt
124thATC v2.0-a44 23:00:16 : Cessna @D-EFSV@ flight plan status: MA031 MAH MUN OBAXA MANAL UNKEN
124thATC v2.0-a44 23:00:16 : Cessna @D-EFSV@ flight plan status: MA031 MAH MUN OBAXA MANAL UNKEN SBG4 SBG
124thATC v2.0-a44 23:00:16 : Call SetILSPath.
124thATC v2.0-a44 23:00:16 : SetILSPath Enter
124thATC v2.0-a44 23:00:16 : SetILSPath Set path from an entry of: Lat 48.002445 Lon 12.892880
124thATC v2.0-a44 23:00:16 : Cessna @D-EFSV@ flight plan status: MA031 MAH MUN OBAXA MANAL UNKEN SBG4 SBG
124thATC v2.0-a44 23:00:16 : SetILSPath GetDistance to 15
124thATC v2.0-a44 23:00:16 : SetILSPath Downwind 337
124thATC v2.0-a44 23:00:16 : ProbeTEST: Dry
124thATC v2.0-a44 23:00:16 : ProbeTEST info: 44
124thATC v2.0-a44 23:00:16 : Rwy Lat 47.804874 Lon 12.996785
124thATC v2.0-a44 23:00:16 : ILS in direct runway heading: 159
124thATC v2.0-a44 23:00:16 : SetILSPath ILS entered: Lat 47.989013 Lon 12.880383
124thATC v2.0-a44 23:00:16 : Cessna @D-EFSV@ flight plan status: MA031 MAH MUN OBAXA MANAL UNKEN SBG4 SBG
124thATC v2.0-a44 23:00:16 : Adding STAR route to FMS at the end of all flight plan entries now...
124thATC v2.0-a44 23:00:16 : ILS Path set to RWY 15.
124thATC v2.0-a44 23:01:45 : reading acc.dat
124thATC v2.0-a44 23:03:31 : Waypoint switch cause: fix reached. Old navigation point 2 MUN
124thATC v2.0-a44 23:03:31 : Speed: 57, headingDifferenceNext: 0.13
124thATC v2.0-a44 23:03:31 : Next navigation point: 3 OBAXA ... Lat: 48.012222 Lon: 11.665556
124thATC v2.0-a44 23:03:34 : Communication: Cessna D-EFSV, turn right heading 209 for OBAXA.
124thATC v2.0-a44 23:03:41 : Communication: turn right heading 209, Cessna D-EFSV
124thATC v2.0-a44 23:04:15 : reading acc.dat
124thATC v2.0-a44 23:06:45 : reading acc.dat
124thATC v2.0-a44 23:09:10 : Waypoint switch cause: fix reached. Old navigation point 3 OBAXA
124thATC v2.0-a44 23:09:10 : Speed: 65, headingDifferenceNext: 40.92
124thATC v2.0-a44 23:09:10 : Next navigation point: 4 MANAL ... Lat: 47.899353 Lon: 11.799956
124thATC v2.0-a44 23:09:10 : Communication: Cessna D-EFSV, turn left heading 145 for MANAL.
124thATC v2.0-a44 23:09:18 : Communication: turn left heading 145, Cessna D-EFSV
124thATC v2.0-a44 23:09:18 : reading acc.dat
124thATC v2.0-a44 23:11:47 : reading acc.dat
124thATC v2.0-a44 23:13:55 : Communication: Cessna D-EFSV, expect UNKEN N, runway in use 15.
TagsNo tags attached.
Attached Filestxt file icon LOWS.txt [^] (19,039 bytes) 2016-08-20 20:05 [Show Content]
txt file icon Log.txt [^] (266,172 bytes) 2016-08-21 09:36

- Relationships

-  Notes
(0000081)
ntnll (administrator)
2016-08-16 19:47

Hi Michael,
thanks for report

I receive the following instructions:

124thATC v2.0-a45 19:44:34 : Communication: Air Italy 2402, expect UNKEN 1R, runway in use 16.

Can you please share your full log.txt for try to replicate the issue?
(0000082)
AdvMichael (updater)
2016-08-20 20:03

Dear Antonello,

probably you have some other navdata version including STAR UNKEN1R and the runways for LOWS in my version are 15/33. I will attach my procedure file for LOWS, which only contains the STAR "UNKEN". Unfortunately I did not keep the log file, however, I will repeat the same flight today for testing and then send you the new log file.

Cheers,
Michael
(0000084)
AdvMichael (updater)
2016-08-21 09:37

Dear Antonello,

I did the same flight again with the same result, attached please find the complete log file now.

Cheers,
Michael

- Issue History
Date Modified Username Field Change
2016-08-14 14:39 AdvMichael New Issue
2016-08-16 19:47 ntnll Note Added: 0000081
2016-08-16 19:47 ntnll Status new => acknowledged
2016-08-16 19:47 ntnll Resolution open => unable to reproduce
2016-08-20 20:03 AdvMichael Note Added: 0000082
2016-08-20 20:05 AdvMichael File Added: LOWS.txt
2016-08-21 09:36 AdvMichael File Added: Log.txt
2016-08-21 09:37 AdvMichael Note Added: 0000084
2016-11-22 05:12 ntnll Status acknowledged => assigned
2016-11-22 05:12 ntnll Assigned To => ntnll


Copyright © 2000 - 2017 MantisBT Team
Powered by Mantis Bugtracker